Next coaching candidates

IANit

Well-known member
Matt Rhule will obviously be considered, but has he won a big game yet? Just seems like Franklin again.

Curt Cignetti can win a big game, but why would he leave Indiana? He seems to be able to win there and has much lower expectations. He does have a buyout.

Dan Mullen? Has PA ties, but seems a little boring. Has failed in high-profile jobs before.

Manny Dias? Likely a good recruiter, but not much of an upgrade over Franklin on game day, if at all.

Can't see Urban Meyer or Nick Saban coming to PSU. I like Lane Kiffin's sense of humor, but I don't see him as much of an upgrade over James.
 
Matt Rhule will obviously be considered, but has he won a big game yet? Just seems like Franklin again.

Curt Cignetti can win a big game, but why would he leave Indiana? He seems to be able to win there and has much lower expectations. He does have a buyout.

Dan Mullen? Has PA ties, but seems a little boring. Has failed in high-profile jobs before.

Manny Dias? Likely a good recruiter, but not much of an upgrade over Franklin on game day, if at all.

Can't see Urban Meyer or Nick Saban coming to PSU. I like Lane Kiffin's sense of humor, but I don't see him as much of an upgrade over James.

I was really impressed with what Lincoln Riley did with USC last night vs UM. His offfense is aggressive. But he's already making 11.5 million per year and why would anyone leave USC for PSU. He's from Texas and played college ball at TTech. And he's only 42.

May have come to replace a legend like Joe, but not to clean up a mess.....
 
Matt Rhule will obviously be considered, but has he won a big game yet? Just seems like Franklin again.

Curt Cignetti can win a big game, but why would he leave Indiana? He seems to be able to win there and has much lower expectations. He does have a buyout.

Dan Mullen? Has PA ties, but seems a little boring. Has failed in high-profile jobs before.

Manny Dias? Likely a good recruiter, but not much of an upgrade over Franklin on game day, if at all.

Can't see Urban Meyer or Nick Saban coming to PSU. I like Lane Kiffin's sense of humor, but I don't see him as much of an upgrade over James.
It is certainly the most attractive job open currently. If your serious goal is a National Championship, you need a top recruiter and you have to provide unlimited NIL money. How much NIL money you can come up with will determine how great of a top recruiter you will attract.
 
From a friend with a friend in the know:

"Inside word from PSU is it was either Pegula or Adidas that financed the firing"
It may be true, but coaching buyouts aren't generally as onerous as they sound. They aren't lump sum deals and the coaches usually mitigate damages by taking another job.
 
Matt Rhule will obviously be considered, but has he won a big game yet? Just seems like Franklin again.

Curt Cignetti can win a big game, but why would he leave Indiana? He seems to be able to win there and has much lower expectations. He does have a buyout.

Dan Mullen? Has PA ties, but seems a little boring. Has failed in high-profile jobs before.

Manny Dias? Likely a good recruiter, but not much of an upgrade over Franklin on game day, if at all.

Can't see Urban Meyer or Nick Saban coming to PSU. I like Lane Kiffin's sense of humor, but I don't see him as much of an upgrade over James.
Rhule - should absolutely be considered, see how his season plays out for those who think he is another version of Franklin
Cignetti - should also be considered. No coach has done more with less and has evaluated transfer talent better than Cignetti. The question is, would he be interested? He has a cash cow at Indiana and rumors have it he hates PSU.

Mullen and Diaz seem like settling to me. Mullen seems more like Franklin 2.0 to me than Rhule, and Manny already had a shot at big time and did worse than Franklin.

Sabin is done with coaching period.

Urban would be the best immediate hire. Many obvious positives. He could preserve the recruiting class, possibly flip some recruits. He could save current players from transferring and he could begin evaluating potential transfers. He would also bring in a quality staff. All this said he has baggage. Can the fan base live with the baggage?

I would give Eliah Drinkwitz a look. He did a great job at App. State and has done well at Mizzou.

Personally, I would be looking at some top coordinators and top head coaches a the lower sub divisions for a long term solution.
 
Last edited:
I was really impressed with what Lincoln Riley did with USC last night vs UM. His offfense is aggressive. But he's already making 11.5 million per year and why would anyone leave USC for PSU. He's from Texas and played college ball at TTech. And he's only 42.

May have come to replace a legend like Joe, but not to clean up a mess.....
I don’t see Riley leaving a blue blood like USC. California is a prime recruiting area. Unless of course he doesn’t like the high taxes.
 
Urban would only be welcome at Penn State if he signed a contract stipulating he won't engage in any scumbaggery, which I doubt will happen.
 
Rhule - should absolutely be considered, see how his season plays out for those who think he is another version of Franklin
Cignetti - should also be considered. No coach has done more with less and has evaluated transfer talent better than Cignetti. The question is, would he be interested? He has a cash cow at Indians and rumors have it he hates PSU.

Mullen and Diaz seem like settling to me. Mullen seems more like Franklin 2.0 to me than Rhule, and Manny already had a shot at big time and did worse than Franklin.

Sabin is done with coaching period. Urban would be the best immediate hire. Many obvious positives. He could preserve the recruiting class, possibly flip some recruits. He could save current players from transferring and he could begin evaluating potential transfers. He would also bring in a quality staff. All this said he has baggage. Can the fan base live with the baggage?

Personally, I would be looking at some top coordinators and top head coaches a the lower sub divisions for a long term solution.
Give Urban his money for 2-3 years. His job is to stabilize and incorporate the little things like controlling the LOS, take away the keys from Kotelnicki, and having a portal and HS recruiting org in place that assesses and brings in top five talent. Salvaging and reinvigorating the Penn State FB brand needs to happen quickly.
 
Tengwell says it was not pressure from ADIDAS that caused the firing.
Kraft said that as well today. BTW, Kraft put on a great performance at today's presser as did Terry Smith.



Athletic director Pat Kraft walked into Beaver Stadium’s press room with a serious look on his face. He then took the stand in front of a packed house for his first public appearance since James Franklin’s firing.

Kraft started by giving his gratitude to Franklin for what he’s done for Penn State. He then spoke on why Franklin was fired and what’s next for Penn State as interim coach Terry Smith takes over for the rest of the season.

Here’s more on what Kraft said.


Why James Franklin was fired

Penn State was off to a 3-3 start to 2025 with losses to Oregon, UCLA and Northwestern in the last three weeks. The team had national championship aspirations heading into the year, but now those chances are out of the picture.

Kraft said those standards were a part of firing Franklin.

“My job is to evaluate everything and make hard decisions for what is in the best interest of our athletes, our program and our department,” Kraft said. “Football is our backbone. We have invested at the highest level with that, with that, comes high expectations. Ultimately, I believe a new leader can help us win a national championship, and now is the right time for this change.”

Kraft said it was a long 48 hours since the ending of the Northwestern game. While he mentioned he was always prepared to make this decision, he also felt it was the best choice for the team moving forward.

“I felt after Saturday and sitting down and looking at everything that where we were and what was in the best interest of my (student-athletes) and where the program was going that this time, we just had to make the hard decision,” Kraft said.

The coaching search

Toward the end of his opening statement, Kraft outlined what he’s looking for in the coaching search.

“Our next coach will be someone who embodies everything Penn State stands for integrity, accountability, toughness, humility and an elite motivator,” Kraft said. “We'll find a coach who can achieve excellence at the highest level, doing it with confidence and conviction.”

Kraft said he wants to keep recruiting as a “pillar” at Penn State. He envisions Happy Valley as a destination school that’ll attract “elite talent.”


That all highlights what Kraft wants to see in Penn State’s program moving forward.

“This is also about the modern era of college football,” Kraft said. “Our next coach needs to be able to maximize elite level resources, attack the transfer portal and develop at the highest level.”

Terry Smith

The Nittany Lions will continue this season with Terry Smith as interim head coach. Kraft said he was comfortable with Smith taking the role due to one key aspect.

“Terry's an elite recruiter,” Kraft said. “Terry has relationships with those kids, and Terry and I first, you know, we talked about many things that are a part of it, and we've got to continue. I think what we will show is that what we're big, we're such a big and historical program that we are going to weather the storm.”

Kraft said “every” Power Four team has reached out to Penn State’s players, but he feels Smith can help with roster retention.

Kraft also said Smith is an option in the search for the Nittany Lions’ next head coach.

“Everybody's under consideration, and I'm going to help Terry do everything he can to run the table,” Kraft said. “But yes, he will be considered a candidate.”

Franklin’s buyout

Kraft declined to dive into the specifics of Franklin’s buyout, but he made clear that the athletics department is taking on the full cost and not the institution.

According to ESPN, Franklin’s buyout is set to be more than $49 million. Franklin was in Year 4 of a 10-year contract he signed in 2021.
 
Rhule - should absolutely be considered, see how his season plays out for those who think he is another version of Franklin
Cignetti - should also be considered. No coach has done more with less and has evaluated transfer talent better than Cignetti. The question is, would he be interested? He has a cash cow at Indiana and rumors have it he hates PSU.

Mullen and Diaz seem like settling to me. Mullen seems more like Franklin 2.0 to me than Rhule, and Manny already had a shot at big time and did worse than Franklin.

Sabin is done with coaching period.

Urban would be the best immediate hire. Many obvious positives. He could preserve the recruiting class, possibly flip some recruits. He could save current players from transferring and he could begin evaluating potential transfers. He would also bring in a quality staff. All this said he has baggage. Can the fan base live with the baggage?

I would give Eliah Drinkwitz a look. He did a great job at App. State and has done well at Mizzou.

Personally, I would be looking at some top coordinators and top head coaches a the lower sub divisions for a long term solution.

Urban would be the best immediate hire. Many obvious positives. He could preserve the recruiting class, possibly flip some recruits. He could save current players from transferring and he could begin evaluating potential transfers. He would also bring in a quality staff. All this said he has baggage. Can the fan base live with the baggage? Certainly, if he wins immediately.

I would give Eliah Drinkwitz a look. He did a great job at App. State and has done well at Mizzou.
And he would likely bring Pribula back with him.
 
Give Urban his money for 2-3 years. His job is to stabilize and incorporate the little things like controlling the LOS, take away the keys from Kotelnicki, and having a portal and HS recruiting org in place that assesses and brings in top five talent. Salvaging and reinvigorating the Penn State FB brand needs to happen quickly.
S8nce there is an open stop on the staff and since Urban is not coaching now, could he be put on staff immediately and start recruiting now? It might be tricky with the current staff. There could be an agreement that he is going to coach for x number of years. This would allow a clean transition to the new head coach.
 
Back
Top