Proposed Redshirt rule

Sheriff Coffee

Well-known member
coaches voted to make redshirt years eligible if the player played in 7 games or less. I believe that the NCAA now has to approve it or not. What does that mean to PSU?

Drew Allar would be available to play another year. He got hurt in game six.
 
coaches voted to make redshirt years eligible if the player played in 7 games or less. I believe that the NCAA now has to approve it or not. What does that mean to PSU?

Drew Allar would be available to play another year. He got hurt in game six.
If the coaches approved it, it seems like the NCAA has no reason to not approve it
 
How many redshirts are they allowed? How many years can a player be in college?
Generally, one. But there are edge cases for medical, hardship and others. So lets say a player has a major injury after playing five games and misses two years. In this case, he could get three years: the year he was injured and the two years of recovery. I think we are getting a kid from BYU or Utah who took two years for a Mormon missionary.
 
coaches voted to make redshirt years eligible if the player played in 7 games or less. I believe that the NCAA now has to approve it or not. What does that mean to PSU?

Drew Allar would be available to play another year. He got hurt in game six.
Another year under a coach that isn't screwing his head up might get Allar to maximize his value. Not sure that is PSU though. Would he even play ahead of Becht?
 
coaches voted to make redshirt years eligible if the player played in 7 games or less. I believe that the NCAA now has to approve it or not. What does that mean to PSU?

Drew Allar would be available to play another year. He got hurt in game six.

Think about that...Regular Season is 12 games. A kid can play in 58% of the games and have not be a counter year.
A kid gets a high ankle sprain and he gets to red shirt. That seems crazy.

This whole thing needs to be reigned in before it collapses.
 
Think about that...Regular Season is 12 games. A kid can play in 58% of the games and have not be a counter year.
A kid gets a high ankle sprain and he gets to red shirt. That seems crazy.

This whole thing needs to be reigned in before it collapses.
Eventually I think they will have unlimited eligibility and possibly no requirements to take classes. You already have guys staying for 7 and 8 years.
 
According to my rulebook...

>Enter college and its football program at 18 years of age, but no later than age 20, if in the military, LDS mission, etc. That's when the five-year clock starts. Maintain a GPA of 2.0 with 30 credit hours per year. After that, it's off to the NFL, the Winnipeg Blue Bombers, or starting up a vodka distilling and marketing company, or something.

>The max roster size is 100 players. Each team's max payroll per season is $20m, which can be doled out among players any way it sees fit. The minimum wage per player is $10,000 per season, regardless of playing time or status.

>Allar should try a year at BC under BOB's tutelage.
 
Last edited:
Enter college and its football program at 18 years of age. That's when the five-year clock starts. Maintain a GPA of 2.0 with 30 credit hours per year. After that, it's off to the NFL, the Winnipeg Blue Bombers, or starting up a vodka distilling and marketing company, or something.
I don't know but this may not survive a challenge in court. Remember, these are now employees, for the most part. If a person is Mormon and has to go on a two year missionary, they could claim that they are being denied based on religion. Injury is the same. I don't know for sure but the courts getting involved and making these kids, for all intent and purpose, employees changes the game.
 
Think about that...Regular Season is 12 games. A kid can play in 58% of the games and have not be a counter year.
A kid gets a high ankle sprain and he gets to red shirt. That seems crazy.

This whole thing needs to be reigned in before it collapses.

It has already collapsed.

Last season I was rooting for our underdog qb to win late in the season.

Now he's gone.

Maybe I should root for the Ole Miss starting rb because he may play here next season?
 
Not your coach either.
It is really no different than the NFL or any other pro league. The pittsburgh steelers represent Pittsburgh in no way, shape or form. They'd all be gone in a NY heartbeat if the league and CBA didn't set up guidelines to make each team more competitive. Almost none of them are from PA. Yet, the league promotes this notion that you are only a fan if you support them through thick and thin. Well at least the steelers have been good. If you live in CLE or Indy, the idea of spending money and time rooting for ineptitude is laughable.

Previously, college teams shared the collective love for those years you spent on campus growing up and maturing. The kids on the team were a microcosm of what it was like to go from being a stupid Frosh to a grizzled senior who couldn't wait to graduate and make some scratch. Now, players and coaches leave like nomads and fans boo a lack of performance.

I may become a fan of John Carol and Westminster and screw all of the big time stuff.
 
It is really no different than the NFL or any other pro league. The pittsburgh steelers represent Pittsburgh in no way, shape or form. They'd all be gone in a NY heartbeat if the league and CBA didn't set up guidelines to make each team more competitive. Almost none of them are from PA. Yet, the league promotes this notion that you are only a fan if you support them through thick and thin. Well at least the steelers have been good. If you live in CLE or Indy, the idea of spending money and time rooting for ineptitude is laughable.

Previously, college teams shared the collective love for those years you spent on campus growing up and maturing. The kids on the team were a microcosm of what it was like to go from being a stupid Frosh to a grizzled senior who couldn't wait to graduate and make some scratch. Now, players and coaches leave like nomads and fans boo a lack of performance.

I may become a fan of John Carol and Westminster and screw all of the big time stuff.

At least I can support my local team in the NFL because it's local.

Personally, for the NFL, I've never been truly locked onto the Giants once I moved.

Also I don't care about the NFL.
 
At least I can support my local team in the NFL because it's local.

Personally, for the NFL, I've never been truly locked onto the Giants once I moved.

Also I don't care about the NFL.
Agreed. For me, the NFL is nothing more than entertainment like any steamed movie or TV show. There is no emotional investment. With PSU I had emotional investment. It will be interesting to see how I feel next year with a new coach, staff, and players. Terry and Tony Rojas are the only ones that I really feel strongly about right now.
 
It has already collapsed.

Last season I was rooting for our underdog qb to win late in the season.

Now he's gone.

Maybe I should root for the Ole Miss starting rb because he may play here next season?
Correct. It is currently collapsing and in obvious free fall. This was easily foreseen. One can only assume the the power brokers ( Presidents, Administrations, Conference leaders) were/are much more enamored with ridiculous amounts of increased revenue than the original purpose of the institutions. —-Many parasites attached to this host.
 
It is really no different than the NFL or any other pro league. The pittsburgh steelers represent Pittsburgh in no way, shape or form. They'd all be gone in a NY heartbeat if the league and CBA didn't set up guidelines to make each team more competitive. Almost none of them are from PA. Yet, the league promotes this notion that you are only a fan if you support them through thick and thin. Well at least the steelers have been good. If you live in CLE or Indy, the idea of spending money and time rooting for ineptitude is laughable.

Previously, college teams shared the collective love for those years you spent on campus growing up and maturing. The kids on the team were a microcosm of what it was like to go from being a stupid Frosh to a grizzled senior who couldn't wait to graduate and make some scratch. Now, players and coaches leave like nomads and fans boo a lack of performance.

I may become a fan of John Carol and Westminster and screw all of the big time stuff.

I agree. That's why I have long said that I think this all will be the end of CFB as we know it. No one cares about the minor leagues.
Thus far, I have been incorrect. The playoff has generated a lot of interest and the money has grown overall. I'm still not sold. Over time, I think fans will become jaded and realize how dumb it is to pay a 19yo 7-figures to play minor league sports and then have that kid leave your team less than a year later for another school paying more. In the end, I think the whole model breaks. IDK how it's gonna go, but I think it's gonna be very different.

My thoughts are that it could go one of two ways.

Option 1. There is a "Super League" of 20ish programs that keep up the madness. Many of them are SEC schools that aren't in NFL markets. Then there is a return to something like we knew in the 90s, where kids go to school to get an education, but are able to make $$ from NIL as it was intended (ie Local commercials, signing autographs at the Ford Dealership, etc).

Option 2: There is a D-League that the NFL pays for as a necessity to develop kids that can't/don't want to go to college. College looks like the 90s description above. The draft pulls kids from both sources.
 
Back
Top